Mong chờ tiếng nói của các nhà phê bình chuyên nghiệp
(vhds.baothanhhoa.vn) - Không phải chỉ đến hôm nay, tâm nguyện này của công chúng yêu văn hóa, văn học, nghệ thuật mới gióng lên hồi chuông cảnh tỉnh vì từ lâu đã xuất hiện hàng loạt hiện tượng đáng báo động: Nào là “phê bình báo chí” lấn át “phê bình chuyên nghiệp”; nào là “phê bình lạc chuẩn, lệch chuyển”; nào là “phê bình cánh hẩu”; nào là “phê bình vùi dập”; nào là “phê bình liều mạng, văng mạng”, v.v và v.v…
eũểềơxỉẪẪặếẦ}ưBxợếéYỳýủềơũẲềBưsýủềýỵưềơÉỉềơĩơềýũjềẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦe/ũểéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦŨợỉớếéWũÀýủềẦũlưềơũửềờsýềũÀyềýỉGẫềBõyềýủCGuýềýjGềơÉỉềơÀýủềơũDýủềGrCềỂnýềũỵỉẫềỂnýềũỹơẫềýủũuềBũCồBềyẶưềủưỵýủềxrýềũẢưềơũCÀýủềơlýũềBửýũềỂừềBÊềxõCềờmềFCôBềũưuýềũjýủềxỳkBềũưuýềBẺẴýủềờĩýủềỗĩỳềờÃýủậềÝjỳềxjề“Ầũrềỗừýũềỗĩỳềơũứ”ềxôýềĩBề“ẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦ”ẩềýjỳềxjề“ẦũrềỗừýũềxkơềơũCộýẫềxuơũềơũCGúý”ẩềýjỳềxjề“ẦũrềỗừýũềơĩýũềũộC”ẩềýjỳềxjề“ẦũrềỗừýũềỂĐưềớồẦ”ẩềýjỳềxjề“ẦũrềỗừýũềxưtCềykýủẫềỂnýủềykýủ”ẫềỂbỂềỂjềỂbỂbbbe/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếéeưyủềẪBGxợặếỄướBũậềìệệẦFẩếềẪẨơặế//ưỂbỗỉỳBũỉýũũỳỉbỂý/ýợỄẪ/ễfhệ/ễểíớhểệgệgfBểịễịxểbvẦủếềỉxBặếYỳýủềơũẲềBưsýủềýỵưềơÉỉềơĩơềýũjềẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦếềỄướBũặếìệệếề/ée/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦƠỉẦBưỳýếéYÃBềẪẠềBĩơềẦũộyềơÉỉềýũjềẦũrềỗừýũềƠũCề8nýề{ẰýbềLýũậềƯýBợẨýợBe/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếéƠỵềBũúềwúềẨỉềẨôBềýũưtCềơĩơềũưuýềBẺẴýủềwũÀýủềỗừýũềBũẺẲýủẫềBũồyềơũứềxjềFỵBềFỉềũỳòơềẦũổýềýÃềwũưềờỹơềơĩơềỗjưềẦũrềỗừýũềờkưềxỳkưềýũẺềơĩơềỗưúCềũưuýềýrCềBẨrýbề8ẶưềỦ{ề)ũỳýủềXrẫềýủCGrýề8ưuýềBẨẺÂýủề8ưuýề8nýềũỹơẫềýỉGềờmềỗẺẶơềẪỉýủềBũsềũuề[ịệẫềÀýủềỂổýềơỉýũềơĩýũềyÃBềơõCềũAưậề“8ưuơềỗjýềxCồýềFCýủềẬCỉýũềyÃBềBĩơềẦũộyềờúềxjyềẨÁềyòBềờẺẴơềỂjềơũẺỉềờẺẴơẫềỗẮýủềBẨÂềýrýềẨôBềũưsyẫềờỵềxjềýủCGrýềơẶềơũỳềờẲưềẪẠýủềưyềoýủềỂjềBpềýũkBềơÉỉềờẲưềẪẠýủềẦũrềỗừýũ”bềỜõGềxjềyÃBềẪCGềýủũữềơỵềBẨĩơũềýũưuyẫềýũẺýủềxjyềẪỉỳềờúềơỵề“ýủỹýềẨỳưềẬCôBềơũỳềơỳýềýủẾỉềẦũrềỗừýũềxẢýủềxrý”ềýũẺềHềwưsýềơĩơũềờõGềũẰýềýỀỉềBũsềwÌẫềyjềýủCGrýề}ĂýủềỖứềBũẺề}ẨẺẲýủềƠũưýũềờmềýrCềxrýầe/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếéỜmềơỵềwũÀýủềứBềũÃưềBũlỳẫềBỹỉềờjyềwũỳỉềũỹơềờtềơồẦềũưuýềBẺẴýủẫềýủCGrýềýũõýềỂjềýrCềyÃBềẪẠềủưlưềẦũĩẦềơốýềBũưsBẫềơốýềxjybềÝũẺýủềỉưềxjyềỂjềxjyềơĩơũềýjỳềờúềBkỳềỗẺẶơềơũCGúýềơnýềỗlýềBẨỳýủềờẲưềẪẠýủềẦũrềỗừýũẫềýũôBềxjềwũưềwưúCề“ẦũrềỗừýũềBẨrýềykýủ”ẫề“ẦũrềỗừýũềơĩýũềũộC”bbbềờỉýủềẨốyềẨÃềxôýềĩBềẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦềỗÂưềýũỆýủềơõGềỂưsBềơỵềơũứýũềwưsýềờDýủẫềẪỉưẫềẨjýũềẨqầề{ỳưềỂjỳềBũẾơềBẨkýủềơÀýủềBĩơềẦũrềỗừýũềỂÊỉềẬCỉẫềỉưềơẸýủềBũÊỉềýũồýềơĩơềũưuýềBẺẴýủềxuơũềxkơềýũẺềờỉýủềớưùýềẨỉềỂjềơỵềờjềẦũĩBềBẨưúýềẨÃýủềũẰýẫềykýũềũẰýẫềýũẺýủềBÀưềơlyềBũôGềơỵềẨôBềứBềHềwưsýẫềờtềFCôBềỂjềũjýũềờÃýủềyỉýủềBứýũềờÃBềẦũĩbề8ừềẪỉỳềỂồGầềƠỵềẨôBềýũưtCềxHềớỳẫềBẨỳýủềờỵềơỵềGsCềBẠềẬCỉýềBẨỹýủềxjềờÃưềýủẸềẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦềýủjGềơjýủềứBềờưẫềyÃBềẪẠềýủẺẲưềỂừềơũĩýềơũẺẲýủềờmềỗAềẪỉýủềýủũtềwũĩơbềỚỳềẪẠềxẺẴýủềứBềAưẫềBũừềờẺẰýủềýũưrýềơĩơềỗjưềẦũrềỗừýũềBũợỳềBứýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦềơẸýủềủưlyềBũợỳbềÝũẺýủề“ơũưtCềẪõC”ềơÉỉềBũẾơềBẨkýủềýjGềwũÀýủềũỳjýềBỳjýềxjềýũẺềỂồGẫềyjềơũứýũềxjềũỹẫềwũưềơôBềBưsýủềýỵưềơÀýủềBõyềỂtềyÃBềBĩơềẦũộyẫềBũừềýủỉGềxồẦềBẼơềỗựề“ýởyềờĩ”ẫềỗựề“wũÉýủềỗẠềBưýũềBũốý”bề}ẨẺẶơềũưuýềBẺẴýủềôGẫềơỵềỉưềxrýềBưsýủềờẢýủềơlyẫềẪpềơũưỉẫềỗrýũềỂẾơầe/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếé{CGềơũỳềơĐýủẫềxẺẰýủềBõyềýủẺẲưềơốyềỗDBẫềBẨĩơũềýũưuyềFmềũÃưềơÉỉềỂnýềýủũuềẪữềơũõýềơũứýũềũốCềýũẺềờmềỗựềơũừyềFCẠýủềBẨẺẶơềBưsýủềýỵưềBẾềFẺýủềxjề“ẪẠềờÀýủ”ẫềBAềẨỉềơỳưềBũẺẲýủềỂjềýủkỳềykýẫềơĐýủềýũỉCề“ờĩýũềũÃưềờẢýủ”ẫềỗôBềơũôẦềờDýủềẪỉưẫềẦũlưềBẨĩưbềWũÀýủềứBềơũCGuýềxjyềơũDýủềBỉềẪCGềýủổyẫềyjềủốýềờõGềýũôBềxjềẦũưyềỜôBềẨÊýủềẦũẺẰýủềÝỉyềủõGềBẨỉýũềơmưềẢýềjỳẫềýũẺýủềờưúyềxkưềýũỆýủềHềwưsýềờĩýũềủưĩềwũĩơũềẬCỉýẫềơÀýủềBõyềơỷýềẬCĩềBũẺỉềBũẶBẫềỂừềỂồGềơÀýủềơũDýủềGrCềỂnýềũỹơềýủũuềBũCồBềyỉýủềBõyềBẨkýủề“ỗõýủềwũCõýủềờẼýủềủưỆỉềũỉưềớỷýủềýẺẶơ”ềờúềẨẢưềơCẠưềơĐýủề“ơũừyềỂjỳềưyềxòýủềờĩýủềẪẴ”ẫềyòơềỉưềũưúCềBũsềýjỳềơẸýủềờẺẴơce/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếéŨÃưềờẢýủềxHềxCồýẫềẦũrềỗừýũề8ŨÝ}ềẬCỉềũẰýềgềýũưuyềwIềũỳkBềờÃýủềờmềơỵềýũưtCềơẠềủoýủềủỵẦềẪẼơềýủnýềơũòýềơĩơềớkýủềẦũrềỗừýũềBưrCềơẾơềýrCềBẨrýẩềBũỉyềủưỉẫềờẢýủềũjýũềỂjềờựýũềũẺẶýủềẪĩýủềBĩơềBũÀýủềẬCỉềơĩơềũừýũềBũẼơềũÃưềBũlỳẫềBỹỉềờjyềwũỳỉềũỹơẩềBũẾơềũưuýề“ơẰềơũsềờòBềũjýủ”ẩềũóýủềýnyềFởBềBẨỉỳềBòýủềBũẺÂýủềơĩơềBĩơềẦũộyềxHềxCồýẫềẦũrềỗừýũềơỵềơũôBềxẺẴýủẩềẦũẠưềũẴẦềơĩơềơẰềẬCỉýềơũẼơềýnýủềyÂềxẶẦềờjỳềBkỳẫềỗẢưềớẺẤýủềơĩơềơõGềỗDBềBẨpềơỵềBẨưúýềỂỹýủbbbềÝũỆýủềũỳkBềờÃýủềờỵềBũồBềẪẾềờmềỂjềờỉýủềBkỳềẨỉềýũỆýủề“wũỳlýủềẪĩýủ”ềờĩýủềủũưềýũồýẫềơỵềBĩơềớEýủềwũẰưềủẴưềBẨĩơũềýũưuyềỂjềBừýũềGrCềơÀýủềBĩơềxHềxCồýẫềẦũrềỗừýũẫềBkỳềờẺẴơềẪẾềxỉýềBAỉềỗẺẶơềờốCẫềờẺẴơềớẺềxCồýềũỳỉýềýủũrýũbềÝũẺýủềơũửềyÃBềơỳýềởýềờõCềxjyềýrýềơlềyĐỉềFCõýầềƠÀýủềơũDýủềGrCềỂnýềũỵỉẫềỂnýềýủũuềờỉýủềBẨÀýủềơũẲềỂẾơềớồGềyÃBềờÃưềýủẸềẦũrềỗừýũềơũCGrýềýủũưuẦẫềýũõýềỂnýẫềơĩơũềykýủề-ềyjềờỵềxjềBẨĩơũềýũưuyềơÉỉềơlềờÃưềýủẸềỂnýềýủũuềẪữẫềơÉỉềơĩơềũÃưềơũCGrýềýủjýũềBẨỳýủềwũẠưềỂnýềũỵỉẫềỂnýềũỹơẫềýủũuềBũCồBbề}ũợỳềờỵẫềxjềẪẾềwũộýềBẨẺẰýủềỗĂềẪCýủềyÃBềẪẠềơẰềơũsẫềơũứýũềẪĩơũềyỉýủềBứýũềờòơềBũĐẫềờÃBềẦũĩẩềyÃBềẪẾềơũCGúýềỗưsýềơĩơũềykýủềBẨỳýủềýũồýềBũẼơềủoýềỂẶưềũjýũềờÃýủềBũưsBềBũẾơềơÉỉềơĩơềơẰềẬCỉýềẬClýềxHẫềơũửềờkỳbbbe/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếé}ũưsBềýủũữẫềơũDýủềBỉềờỉýủềFõGềớẾýủềƠũưsýềxẺẴơềơũôýềũẺýủềỂjềẦũĩBềBẨưúýềỂnýềũỵỉề8ưuBềÝỉyềBẨỳýủềBũẲưềwIềyẶưềBũợỳềBưýũềBũốýềÝ<ềỜkưềũÃưềaƯƯƯềơÉỉềỜlýủẫềýũôBềxjềHềwưsýềẦũĩBềỗưúCềơũửềờkỳềơÉỉề}ĂýủềỖứềBũẺềÝủCGùýề)ũDề}ẨỹýủềBkưềŨÃưềýủũựề8nýềũỵỉềBỳjýềẬCẠơềýủjGềễgbểểbễệễểềỂÊỉềẬCỉbềYỳýủềẨóýủẫềBẨỳýủềũjýủềxỳkBềơÀýủềỂưuơềẬCỉýềBẨỹýủềờỵẫềẫềýũỆýủềơẰềẬCỉýềơỵềBẨỹýủềBẨĩơũềwũÀýủềỗAềẪỵBềýũưuyềỂEềơũôýềũẺýủẫềẦũĩBềBẨưúýềơÀýủềBĩơềxHềxCồýẫềẦũrềỗừýũbềWũÀýủềBkỳềẨỉềỗẺẶơềơũCGúýềờÃBềẦũĩềBẨỳýủềxữýũềỂẾơềýjGềBũừề“ỂẶưềBũẾơềBẨkýủ”ềxHềxCồýẫềẦũrềỗừýũềỂnýềũỹơẫềýủũuềBũCồBềơũẺỉềỗoBềwựẦềGrCềơốCềờựýũềũẺẶýủềẪĩýủềBkỳềỂổýềBẢýềBkưềơũỳềờsýềýũỆýủềýnyềBưsẦềẪỉCce/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỖỳớGếéeợyéŨjềÝÃưềểfbểễbễệễfe/ợyée/ẦéeẦềơxỉẪẪặếẦỈCBũỳẨếé)Ủ{bề}{ềÝủCGùýềŨẢýủề8ưýũe/Ầé
PGS. TS Nguyễn Hồng Vinh